The 5.9L and 6.7L Cummins are both legendary inline-six diesels, but they suit different buyers. The 5.9L (through early 2007) is prized for mechanical simplicity, while the 6.7L (2007.5 and up) makes more power and torque but carries more emissions equipment. Here is how to decide.
Power and towing
The 6.7L is the stronger engine from the factory, with more displacement, a variable-geometry turbo, and higher torque ratings that make it the better straight-line tow rig. The 5.9L, especially the common-rail 2003-2007 trucks, still tows extremely well and responds strongly to modest tuning and fueling upgrades.
Emissions equipment
This is the biggest practical difference. The 6.7L adds a diesel particulate filter (DPF), and later trucks add SCR with diesel exhaust fluid. Those systems work, but they add maintenance items: DPF regeneration, EGR components, and the variable-geometry turbo actuator. The 5.9L has far less of this, which is why it is so popular with owners who value simplicity.
Maintenance and known issues
- 5.9L 24V: watch the fuel lift pump and the injection pump on 2003-2007 common-rail trucks
- 6.7L: budget for VGT turbo actuator, EGR cooler, DPF, and the grid heater bolt fix
- Both: keep up with fuel filtration to protect the injectors and pump
Which one is right for you?
If you want the simplest, easiest-to-service truck and do not need the newest emissions compliance, a clean common-rail 5.9L is hard to beat. If you want maximum factory power, the latest safety and towing features, and you are willing to maintain the emissions hardware, the 6.7L is the better daily and tow platform. Both will run past 300,000 miles when maintained.
Frequently asked questions
Is the 5.9 or 6.7 more reliable?
Both are reliable when maintained. The 5.9L has fewer emissions parts to service; the 6.7L makes more power but needs upkeep on the DPF, EGR, and VGT turbo.
Does the 6.7 Cummins require DEF?
Trucks from roughly 2013 on use SCR and diesel exhaust fluid. Earlier 6.7L trucks (2007.5-2012) use a DPF without DEF.
Which tows better?
The 6.7L has higher factory torque and towing ratings, but a well-maintained common-rail 5.9L tows very capably.
Need the part?
We stock the parts these trucks need. Shop all 6.7L Cummins parts →